"G.W. Bush." Mark Teixeira, New York Yankees 1st Baseman

"Satchel Paige. And Bob Gibson, my idol." Dwight "Doc" Gooden, former pitcher for the New York Yankees

"The late great Jerry Coleman." David Cone, former pitcher for the New York Yankees

"Jason Binn." James Lipton, host of Inside the Actors Studio

"Ernest Shackleton." Mark Messier, Canadian former professional hockey player

"Beyoncé. I would love to pick her brain; she is just a fantastic performer and artist and who better to share a steak with—she'd probably pick a giant Porterhouse." Christina Milian

"Well, Lou Gehrig, of course. And not just for personal reasons—he's amazing guy." John Wernke, Bronx Bombers Broadway actor

"Nelson Mandela. He just passed recently and I wish I'd been able to meet somebody like that. This is somebody that's going to go down in the books like Martin Luther King Jr." Jeremiah Bitsui, Breaking Bad actor

"Bruce Springsteen." James Allen, Hard Rock International chairman

Bernie Williams, musical guest and former Center Fielder for the New York Yankees. The best pitcher he's every played against? Pedro Martinez, a "pitching ninja."